Whose loyalty card is most worth it?

-15% Stop & Shop card, best in market

Stop & Shop's: free, and about 15% off a staples basket versus shelf price. Most chains offer no card at all.

Avg loyalty-card savings on staples (%)

• Stop & Shop: 15.2
• ShopRite: 11.8
• Weee!: 8.5
• ACME: 8.4
• Wegmans (NJ): 2.8
• FreshDirect: 2.2
• Wegmans (PA): 1.6
• Wegmans: 0.2

See Stop & Shop

Method: mean card discount across the 20-item staples basket, per chain. Data: July 2026.